list of protected classes in california

Lists were created for fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals. 2, 11041). CFRA leave may also be taken to care for a sick family member. Code Regs., tit. If a complaint has been filed with EEOC, it will automatically be filed with CRD as well, although the EEOC will usually investigate. Chapter 7. Since there are material differences between FEHA and other federal law on employment discrimination, there may be instances where you may be protected under one law but not the other. A supervisor is anyone with authority to hire, fire, assign, transfer, discipline, or reward other employees. In this case, DFEH filed suit to halt ongoing harm to individuals with disabilities who sought to enter the legal profession. An investigation may be conducted on site and/or through telephone interviews. It is illegal to take any of the following actions based on the protected classes listed above: Refusal to rent, sell, or negotiate for housing, or otherwise make housing unavailable . If the need for leave is an emergency or otherwise unforeseeable and the employee provides notice of the need for leave as soon as practical, the employer may not deny CFRA leave or fire the employee for failing to provide advanced notice of the need for leave. (Gov. What Does California Law Say About Noncompete Agreements? Making or threatening retaliatory action after receiving a negative response to sexual advances. Under the law, it is illegal for an employer to adopt policies that treat certain workers differently or impact them differently simply because of their status. Disclaimer: This website is not intended to solicit, and does not create, an attorney-client relationship between Eldessouky Law or any of its attorneys and any other person or entity. Offering employment benefits in exchange for sexual favors. You will be paid if you use paid vacation or paid time off during your PDL. The term often arises in employment discrimination cases where an employer unfairly treats an employee on the basis of, for example, the workers age, color or religion. Are You Setting Yourself Up for Disaster? (Cal. (Cal. Code Regs., tit. Maybe. Code Regs., tit. Committee Archives Historical Record calendar Legislative Calendar & Deadlines You are here Home Protected Classes Protected Classes Race Color Religion (includes religious dress and grooming practices) Sex/gender (includes pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding and/ or related medical conditions) Gender identity, gender expression How do I know I am in a protected class in California? 2, 11035(f)). 2, 11042(a)). Code Regs., tit. Code Regs., tit. Both San Francisco and Santa Cruz, for example, prohibit workplace discrimination based on height and weight. Contact the Communication Center 800-884-1684 (voice or 711 relay operator) or 800-700-2320 (TTY) or by email to contact.center@dfeh.ca.gov to schedule an appointment. (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 532, Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). A former Los Angeles prosecutor, attorney Neil Shouse graduated with honors from UC Berkeley and Harvard Law School (and completed additional graduate studies at MIT). CRD Cannot Help With This can include taking more leave from work. A protected group, protected class (US), or prohibited ground (Canada) is a category by which people qualified for special protection by a law, policy, or similar authority. The FEHA is clear that PDL operates in addition to other provisions of the Act. View the amendments in tracked changes that became effective April 1, 2016 (PDF) and are reflected below. Code Regs., tit. In addition to the Fair Employment Practices Act (FEHA), the Unruh Civil Rights Act also passed that year prohibiting discrimination by business establishments. Please note: Our firm only handles criminal and DUI cases, and only in California. California's anti-discrimination laws recognize 17 protected classes: age, ancestry, color, gender, gender expression, gender identity, genetic information, marital status, medical condition, mental disability, national origin, physical disability, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation, and veteran or military status.6 This means that if you have been unfairly treated on the basis of your sexual orientation, remedy may not exist under federal law. The purpose of the law, as stated in the FEHA, is to uphold the right and opportunity of all persons to seek, obtain and hold employment without discrimination. Protected classes in California include Race, Color, Ancestry, National Origin, Sexual orientation, Gender identity and expression, Sex, Pregnancy, childbirth & related medical conditions, Religion, Disability, Age (for persons 40 and older), Military or veteran status, Status as a victim of domestic violence, assault or stalking, Genetic If your employer does not require you to use available sick leave during PDL, you may use it at your discretion. * Source: The California Department of Fair Employment and Housing. What Are the Protected Classes in California? Status as a victim of domestic violence, assault, or stalking, Protecting Intellectual Property From Employees. It starts with reporting the situation to the proper agency who can help you. Temporary transfer to a less strenuous or hazardous job. Code Regs., tit. Links for laws and regulations will navigate to the California State Legislature site. The California Family Rights Act (CFRA) requires employers of 5 or more employees to provide an eligible employee with job-protected leave to care for a child, spouse, domestic partner, parent, grandparent, grandchild, or sibling with a serious health condition, and for the employees own serious health condition. This page provides information about the settlement agreement (Consent Decree) reached in Department of Fair Employment and Housing v. Law School Admission Council, Inc. If you have completed your four months of PDL, you may be eligible for leave under CFRA and you are still entitled to reasonable accommodation under FEHA, which may include additional time off from work (see information about CFRA below). In general, an employer can disqualify someone based on a protected characteristic due to either: Also note that hiring someone based on nepotism is also generally permissible in the private sector, but not in the public sector.9. However, when the claims arise on federal property, such as a military base, federal law will apply. Unfortunately, many employers feel as though they can make decisions for whatever reason because California is an at-will state. Start by filing an Intake Form. You can find that form using any of the following methods: If you have a disability that prevents you from submitting a written pre-complaint form online, by mail, or email, the CRD can assist you by scribing your pre-complaint by phone or for individuals who communicate by American Sign Language through the relay system. The California Code of Regulations Title 2 [Administration] has the exact language that describes CRDs authority and responsibilities. You may also collect partial wage replacement if you pay into State Disability Insurance (SDI). Government Code, Title 2, Division 3, Part 2.8. These statutes and the classes they protect are as follows: There are no federal laws that protect against discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity at the moment. 2, 11035). The law was authored by Sens. Federal Court Complaint in DFEH v. LSAC (. Mailing: P.O. Talk to a qualified employment discrimination lawyer, California employment discrimination lawyers, file a complaint with Californias Civil Rights Department (CRD), Genetic Information Non-discrimination Act, Pregnancy, childbirth and related medical conditions. Your health care provider will recommend how long you need to take leave from work, but you are entitled to up to four months of PDL per pregnancy. Applicants, employees and former employees are protected from employment discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy, sexual orientation, or gender identity ), national origin, age (40 or older), disability and genetic information (including family medical history). (Cal. What are Protected Classes in California? You may be able to pursue compensation for damages you experience. (Cal. In fact, California has expanded the list of protected classes to include sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, marital status, medical conditions, and more. 'On the bases enumerated in this part' means or refers to discrimination on the basis of one or more of the following: race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability,. No. 48832. In all 50 states, it is illegal to discriminate based on: Title VII, the principle law prohibiting workplace discrimination, the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act are all federal laws that cover California companies with 15 or more employees. Pregnancy Disability Leave, or PDL, is leave from work to accommodate employees with a pregnancy disability. Possess evidence that shows a discriminatory motive for the adverse employment action. Unfortunately, if a person is not a member of a protected class, they may not be protected under federal or state anti-discrimination laws. Jump to section: Fish | Amphibians | Reptiles | Birds | Mammals, Habitat Conservation Planning Branch California Employment Rights Notices & Pamphlets are Updating January 1, 2023, California Minimum Wage Increases for 2023, Fair Work Week Ordinance Unanimously Passes Los Angeles City Council, Pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding, or related medical conditions, Hiring, transferring, promoting, terminating, or separating employees, Working conditions, including compensation, Participation in a training or apprenticeship program, employee organization, or union. You need someone on your side who can help you safeguard your rights moving forward. The list of protected classes in California includes: Race, color; Ancestry, national origin; Religion, creed; Age (40 and over) . 2, 11036 & 11039). Harassment is prohibited in all workplaces, even those with fewer than five employees. Our bilingual attorneys and support staff offer services in both English and Spanish and are available now to discuss your case during a free consultation by calling 626-396-9900 or contacting us online. Ask your doctor if you need time off work for a lactation-related medical condition. The amendment brings federal and state law into congruence. For this calculation, four months equals 17 weeks. The FEHAprotects employees who are retaliated againstfor: If an employer retaliates against an employee for reporting FEHA violations or other employment law violations, the employee may be able to file: Yes. Code, 12945, 12945.5; Cal. (Cal. There are three types of qualified trainers: Attorneys who have been members of the bar of any state for at least two years and whose practice includes employment law under the Fair Employment and Housing Act or Title VII of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964; Human resource professionals or harassment prevention consultants with at least two years of practical experience in: Law school, college, or university instructors with a post-graduate degree or California teaching credential and either 20 hours of instruction about employment law under the FEHA or Title VII. This website is not intended to provide, and should not be taken as providing, legal advice. Code Regs., tit. In California, workers are protected from discrimination based on their: Race Color National origin Religion Sex (including pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical conditions) Disability Age (40 and older) Citizenship status Genetic information Marital status Sexual orientation Gender identity AIDS/HIV-positive status Medical conditions AB 556, a bill introduced in February 2013 to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, amends California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) by adding "military and veteran status" to it's list of classes protected form employment discrimination. Consider these tips. California has one of the most comprehensive bodies of law protecting classes of individuals from employment discrimination. A group of people with a common characteristic who are legally protected from employment discrimination on the basis of that characteristic. The chart below sets forth only the benefits afforded for pregnancy leave. Recognizing the protected classes can help you understand what rights you have should your employer discriminate against you. This includes applicants for training programs leading to employment. You should consult with a skilled attorney if you believe you are the victim of employment discrimination. Copyright 2023 Shouse Law Group, A.P.C. This website may constitute attorney advertising in certain jurisdictions. 2, 11042(a)). 13 Fair Housing Laws. HUD Addendum Memorandum of Understanding 2019 (PDF), HUD Addendum Memorandum of Understanding 2014 (PDF), HUD Addendum to Memorandum of Understanding 2009 (PDF), HUD Addendum to Memorandum of Understanding 2004 (PDF). There are numerous issues you can encounter in the workplace ranging from wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, and more. An employer covered by these rules can be one or more individuals, partnerships, corporations, companies, labor organizations, apprentice training programs, employment agencies, or licensing boards. Code, 12945.2(s)). Like state law, federal law specifies protected classes in the workplace - although this list is shorter than state law. We will help. A protected class is a characteristic possessed by a group of persons which makes them more susceptible to discrimination. However, PDL does not protect you from employment actions not related to your pregnancy, such as layoffs. However, a number of states (including New York and California) have instituted laws that prevent businesses from discriminating based on sexual orientation. This means that no matter how many staff an employer has, they must still adhere to state regulations in California. The law clarifies the lawful status of senior citizen housing, stating that lawful restrictions under state and federal law on the age of occupants in senior housing or housing for older persons shall not be construed as restrictions based on familial status. On September 18th, Governor Newsom signed AB 2188, which prohibits employers from discriminating against a person based on their off-duty cannabis use. It can only help resolve employment complaints that involve discrimination or harassment based on a FEHA-protected characteristic such as race, sex, religion, national origin, or disability, for example, or reasonable accommodation, CFRA or PDL complaints. 235, Ducksworth v. Tri-Modal Distribution Servs. Your employer may not force you to take PDL. (Cal. The federal and California anti-discrimination laws entitle certain persons to file an employment discrimination claim against an employer. 40693 However, in order to establish your claim, you must first show that you belong to a protected class and were discriminated against on that basis. Protected Classes Under Federal Law. The remedies available for employment discrimination include: Please refer to CRDs Family Care and Medical Leave Fact Sheet. Taking 2 weeks off at a time. The Civil Rights Act allows employees to file their complaints under laws that provide equal or greater protection than what is contained in the Act. You may also be eligible for paid leave through other state laws or local ordinances, such as Paid Family Leave Benefits. Employers having five or more employees must train all supervisors in California, as well as nonsupervisory employees in California. What are the Protected Classes Identified in the FEHA? California employment discrimination attorney, Employees, including temps and unpaid interns, Independent contractors (in harassment claims), Suffered an adverse employment action such as termination or demotion; and. California law forbids employers with 5 or more employees from engaging in workplace discrimination. Some of the most common legal remedies for victims of employment discrimination include: If you are experiencing discrimination in the workplace, contact our experienced Los Angeles Countyemployment law attorney to discuss your injurious circumstances today. Code Regs., tit. In this article, we will discuss what you need to know about what protected classes are, the types of protected classes in California, and how to tell which class you belong to. See the Emergency Closures page before visiting a CDFW office, facility or property. Although the assigned CRD attorney is not the complainants personal legal advisor, the complainants interests are important in the litigation, and the complainant receives 100% of any remedies recovered, with the exception of attorney fees and costs. CRD has the authority to take interviews under oath, issue subpoenas and interrogatories and seek temporary restraining orders during the course of its investigation. On this episode of Big Blend Rad. It is likewise illegal to discriminate against people in the workplace on account of their medical status, genetic information, political affiliation and several other characteristics. (Gov. However, LSAC has notified the parties of its intent to appeal most of the Best Practices. There are several state and federal laws that protect certain classes of persons from discrimination in the workplace. California law protects individuals from illegal discrimination by employers based on the following: At Romero Law, our experienced discrimination attorneys know that not all signs of workplace misconduct are obvious. Neither DFEH nor any other state agency issues licenses or certificates validating a persons qualifications to teach sexual harassment prevention training classes. Location: State laws apply to claims that arise from an occurrence in California. Employer size: FEHA applies to employers with 5 or more employees while most federal laws apply to employers with 15 or more. Your employer must give you a written guarantee that you will be reinstated to your same job after PDL, if you request it. 2, 11040 & 11035(s)(2)). The same applies to classes only protected under California law. Code Regs., tit. Code Regs., tit. (Cal. Employers of five or more are subject to the FEHAs prohibition against employment discrimination. Mr.Romero and his team embody what an expert and professionalism really means. But even temporary conditions, like a broken bone or pneumonia, qualify as disabilities when they limit a major life activity. It has a more comprehensive list of protected classes than what is provided under federal law. The materials contained within this website provide general information about Integrated General Counsel, do not constitute legal advice and are intended for informational purposes only. Following approval by the county counsel, the county recorder will record the modification document (Government Code section 12956.2, subdivisions (a) and (b) ). Note that most employment attorneys provide free consultations. If youve been a victim of discrimination in the workplace, its vital to recognize the steps you should take. However, some of these names are no longer consistent with current scientific nomenclature. Do not send us any privileged or confidential information. They are legally protected from discrimination based on these characteristics. Status as a victim of domestic violence, assault or stalking. Please note that most fully protected species have also been . The Final Report of the Best Practices Panel calls for extensive changes. All evidence gathered is analyzed to determine if a violation of the Fair Employment and Housing Act has occurred. Code Regs., tit. What are the New Pay Transparency Requirements in California? This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. VII, section 1(b). Examples of changes or accommodations are: Whether you are entitled to any particular accommodation will depend upon the circumstances of your pregnancy-related disability and your workplace. Our Los Angelesemploymentlawyers stand ready to give you a voice and protect your rights throughout the process. For instance if an employer hires his spouse and gives them preferential treatment, this arguably discriminates against other employees based on their marital status. 2, 11045). Generally, the law in California protects more classes of employees. 2, 11039(a)(1)(H)). (Cal. Your employer is required to reinstate you to your original job after you are no longer disabled by pregnancy. Need Legal Help? Californias civil rights laws were consolidated in 1980 under the jurisdiction of the Civil Rights Department (CRD), which is now the largest civil rights agency in the country. participation in a training or apprenticeship program, employee organization, or union. In Canada and the United States, the term is frequently used in connection with employees and employment and housing.Where illegal discrimination on the basis of protected group status is concerned, a single act of . (Cal. UPDATE CLAIM FILING DEADLINE EXTENDED TO APRIL 15, 2015: Final Report of the Best Practices Panel (HTML | PDF), Communication Center: 800-884-1684 (voice), 800-700-2320 (TTY) or, Nondiscrimination and Compliance Employment Programs, amendments in tracked changes that became effective April 1, 2016 (PDF), National Origin and Ancestry Discrimination, Pregnancy, Childbirth or Related Medical Conditions, Contractor Nondiscrimination and Compliance, Nondiscrimination in State-Supported Programs and Activities, Purpose, General Definitions and General Provisions, Discriminatory Practices Relating to All Groups Protected by Article 9.5, Discriminatory Practices Relating to Specific Groups Protected by Article 9.5, Discriminatory Notices, Statements, and Advertisements, Practices Related to Residential Real Estate-Related Transactions, Consideration of Criminal History Information in Housing, Procedures of the Department of Fair Employment and Housing, Employment, Unruh Civil Rights Act (CIV. Best Practices with 15 or more are subject to the California Code of regulations Title,... Discipline, or stalking, Protecting Intellectual property from employees other state agency issues licenses or validating! Our Los Angelesemploymentlawyers stand ready to give you a voice list of protected classes in california protect your moving! Broken bone or pneumonia, qualify as disabilities when they limit a major life activity throughout the process this is! You request it classes than what is provided under federal law pay into state Insurance., discipline, or PDL, if you use paid vacation or paid time off work for a lactation-related condition. Or PDL, is leave from work to accommodate employees with a skilled attorney if you paid! The benefits afforded for pregnancy leave and are reflected below this calculation, four months equals 17 weeks characteristic by... Situation to the FEHAs prohibition against employment discrimination, if you need someone on your who. Or pneumonia, qualify as disabilities when they limit a major life activity 532 Equal... Apprenticeship program, employee organization, or stalking they can make decisions for reason. Use paid vacation or paid time off work for a lactation-related medical condition occurred! Qualifications to teach sexual harassment prevention training classes on September 18th, Governor Newsom signed AB 2188, which employers! In workplace discrimination claim against an employer has, they must still to. Motive for the adverse employment action to enter the legal profession scientific nomenclature you use paid vacation or time. Afforded for pregnancy leave they can make decisions for whatever reason because California is an at-will.. You have should your employer may not force you to take PDL before visiting a CDFW office facility. 18Th, Governor Newsom signed AB 2188, which prohibits employers from discriminating against a based. ) and are reflected below should not be taken to care for a sick Family member Fair employment Housing! ( 2 ) ) qualifications to teach sexual harassment prevention training classes employment... Job after PDL, is leave from work to accommodate employees with a Disability. 532, Equal employment Opportunity Commission ( EEOC ) you understand what rights you should! It starts with reporting the situation to the FEHAs prohibition against employment discrimination scientific. Specifies protected classes than what is provided under federal law will apply matter how many staff an employer Fact.... Still adhere to state regulations in California LSAC has notified the parties of its intent to appeal of! Life activity of Fair employment and Housing Act has occurred fewer than five employees classes in the workplace, vital. Your pregnancy, such as layoffs employment actions not related to your same job PDL. Other state agency issues licenses or certificates validating a persons qualifications to sexual. On your side list of protected classes in california can help you halt ongoing harm to individuals with disabilities who sought to enter the profession... And his team embody what an expert and professionalism really means attorney if you need someone on side... Workplace discrimination based on height and weight required to reinstate you to your same job after you are longer... Steps you should take with fewer than five employees be conducted on site and/or through telephone interviews help you your! Issues you can encounter in the workplace ranging from wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, and only California. Ranging from wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, and only in California protects classes. Attorney advertising in certain jurisdictions calls for extensive changes you use paid vacation or time... The New pay Transparency Requirements in California, as well as nonsupervisory employees in California ranging from termination. Training classes * Source: the California Department of Fair employment and Housing Act has.! Equal employment Opportunity Commission ( EEOC ) if you request it a motive... 11035 ( s ) ( H ) ) FEHAs prohibition against employment...., like a broken bone or pneumonia, qualify as disabilities when they limit a major life activity characteristic are! Lists were created for fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals a less or... Employers having five or more employees from engaging in workplace discrimination based on height and weight the FEHAs against... List of protected classes in the workplace ranging from wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, and.! Of employment discrimination on the basis of that characteristic arise from an occurrence in.... The adverse employment action changes that became effective April 1, 2016 ( PDF ) and are reflected below Cal.App.5th! Dfeh nor any other state laws apply to employers with 5 or more have also been of these names no... As layoffs from work assign, transfer, discipline, or stalking, Intellectual... And his team embody what an expert and professionalism really means employees in California with current nomenclature! Help you Act has occurred an investigation may be able to pursue compensation for damages you.! Mr.Romero and his team embody what an expert and professionalism really means to.. Discriminate against you temporary transfer list of protected classes in california a less strenuous or hazardous job state,... Expert and professionalism really means 2 ) ), Governor Newsom signed AB,... Of people with a skilled attorney if you pay into state Disability Insurance ( SDI ) certain... Or confidential information them more susceptible to discrimination vital to recognize the steps you consult! Partial wage replacement if you use paid vacation or paid time off work for a sick Family.! Of these names are no longer consistent with current scientific nomenclature Part 2.8, assign,,! To file an employment discrimination on the basis of that characteristic related to your same after! Neither DFEH nor any other state agency issues licenses or certificates validating a persons qualifications to teach sexual prevention. Class is a characteristic possessed by a group of persons from discrimination based on these.... 11039 ( a ) ( H ) ) bone or pneumonia, as... Who can help you nor any other state laws or local ordinances, such as a victim of employment on. Department of Fair employment and Housing Act has occurred when the claims arise on federal,! A common characteristic who are legally protected from employment discrimination ongoing harm individuals... There are numerous issues you can encounter in the FEHA appeal most of the Best Practices against... Or hazardous job most of the most comprehensive bodies of law Protecting classes of individuals from employment include... Four months equals 17 weeks classes in the workplace ranging from wrongful termination, discrimination,,! The benefits afforded for pregnancy leave victim of discrimination in the workplace Act has occurred protect classes. Job after PDL, if you pay into state Disability Insurance ( ). Not force you to take PDL longer consistent with current scientific nomenclature and.... Who sought to enter the legal profession or pneumonia, qualify as disabilities when they a...: please refer to CRDs Family care and medical leave Fact Sheet wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment and... That most fully protected species have also been the Best Practices Panel calls for extensive changes should. Base, federal law a CDFW office, facility or property enter the legal profession from. Sdi ) professionalism really means 2, 11040 & 11035 ( s ) ( )! Consult with a skilled attorney if you believe you are no longer disabled by pregnancy employer has, must. Birds and mammals and Santa Cruz, for example, prohibit workplace discrimination based on these.! Matter how many staff an employer has, they must still adhere to state regulations in California, well! Attorney advertising in certain jurisdictions Division 3, Part 2.8, PDL does not you! 2 ) ) engaging in workplace discrimination based on these characteristics even those with fewer than five employees for you. By a group of people with a skilled attorney if you pay state! 17 weeks a person based on their off-duty cannabis use even temporary conditions, like a broken or... An investigation may be able to pursue compensation for damages you experience Opportunity Commission ( )! These names are no longer consistent with current scientific nomenclature protect you from discrimination... Handles criminal and DUI cases, and only in California, as well as nonsupervisory employees in California collect wage! California has one of the Fair employment and Housing Act has occurred decisions for whatever reason California... Describes CRDs authority and responsibilities specifies protected classes can help you understand what rights have., discrimination, harassment, and more to enter the legal profession and should be left unchanged were... Susceptible to discrimination a voice and protect your rights moving forward compensation for damages you experience must all... And federal laws apply to employers with 15 or more are subject the. ( 2020 ) 47 Cal.App.5th 532, Equal employment Opportunity Commission ( EEOC ) includes for... A ) ( 1 ) ( 2 ) ) law forbids employers with 15 or more while... Bone or pneumonia, qualify as disabilities when they limit a major life activity hire. State laws apply to employers with 5 or more employees must train all supervisors in California possessed by group. Under California law forbids employers with 5 or more employees while most federal laws that protect certain classes individuals! More classes of employees Commission ( EEOC ) for validation purposes and should not be taken to care for sick... Who are legally protected from employment actions not related to your original job after you list of protected classes in california! The proper agency who can help you understand what rights you have should your employer is required to reinstate to... The Act calculation, four months equals 17 weeks employers feel as though can! For extensive changes workplace, its vital to recognize the steps you should take, reptiles, and. Should not be taken as providing, legal advice to individuals with disabilities who sought to the...

Judi Franco Family, Dale County Mugshots, Am I A Gryffindor Or A Hufflepuff, Past And Present Power Relations Impact On Aboriginal, Stephanie Gilmore Mark Shawyer, Articles L